LOGIN
User Name
Password
Remember me


Register...Forgot password?
Main menu
Leagues
Gonzaga
Blue Max
Cartagena
Wooden Ships...
King Me!
VampiRing
Forum Message
Previous messagePost on the new forumNext message

City:Roma IT
Personal Data:Male, born: August 23 1962
HomePage or other cool site:http://https://www.facebook.com/GiovanniGugliantini
Membership23years 187days ago.
Last Login18days 19h ago.
Last Move18days 19h ago.
gugliandalf is currently Offline!Send a mail to gugliandalf


Message header
Area/Game:General
Topic:General
Subject:Re: Rankings - Suggestions
Posted by: gugliandalf - 23years 153days ago.
Message text
Zif said:


>the Red Baron score was about how much planes he shooted down or about the kill/death ratio?

>ALL aces score were a kill/death ratio. Of course, death was a constant = 1.

I don't understand it very well

With death=1, the values turn out equal


But I can say you something, [...]


Ehm... it happens I'm re-reading Richtofen's diary just in these days.

Now, it depends on how you consider the july 1917 episode. Richtofen wasn't really shot down: he was (badly) wounded, but managed to escape and land on his own.

In March 1917, he was also "shot down": he draw ( ) a "smoke" chit and a "fuel tank hit: loose X fuel", switched off his engine and glided to a safe landing spot.

Is it a "kill"? I don't think: looks more like someone gliding to his map side with engine smashed.

IMO, "death" means exactly that: "pilot killed", "EXPLODE!" or structural damage enough to rip off your tail/wings or break your fuselage.

Or, if you please:
"I opened fire. The bullets ripped of the tailplanes and tore the fuselage. Where bullets hit, flames appeared. Too low! A little pull ath the stick... my airplane lifts a little, [...]. A burst tore the side of the aircraft. The pilot turned and rised his head. I saw for an instant his eyes shine behind goggles, then he fell on his seat. [...] His aircraft shuddered, rolled and fell."
Cpt. Roy Brown account on Richtofen's death. (I apologize for possible discrepancies, I translated an italian traslation).

So, IMO, Richtofen's ratio keeps 80:1.

Back to the messages list
Messages thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

23years 154days Zif Re: Rankings - Suggestions
 23years 154days Gladiatore Re: Rankings - Suggestions
 23years 153days webmaster Re: Rankings - Suggestions
  23years 153days gugliandalf Re: Rankings - Suggestions
  23years 153days Zif Re: Rankings - Suggestions
   23years 153days Zif Re: Rankings - Suggestions
    23years 153days gugliandalf Re: Rankings - Suggestions
    23years 153days Zif Re: Rankings - Suggestions
     23years 153days gugliandalf Re: Rankings - Suggestions
      23years 153days Falconfab Re: Rankings - Suggestions
       23years 153days Zif Re: Rankings - Suggestions
       23years 152days gugliandalf Re: Rankings - Suggestions
        23years 153days Falconfab Re: Rankings - Suggestions
         23years 153days Zif Re: Rankings - Suggestions
    21years 286days CdtWeasel Re: Rankings - Suggestions
Next thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

23years 145days oxy10 [Blue Max] Damage Codes
23years 145days Zif Re: [Blue Max] Damage Codes
23years 144days oxy10 Re: [Blue Max] Damage Codes
23years 145days gugliandalf Re: [Blue Max] Damage Codes
21years 280days CdtWeasel Re: [Blue Max] Damage Codes
Previous thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

21years 280days greif8 [WS&IM][OT] How to access WS&IM
21years 280days Sabelkatten Re: [WS&IM][OT] How to access WS&IM
 21years 280days greif8 Re: [WS&IM][OT] How to access WS&IM
Page generated in: 16.79688 milliseconds.