LOGIN
User Name
Password
Remember me


Register...Forgot password?
Main menu
Leagues
Gonzaga
Blue Max
Cartagena
Wooden Ships...
King Me!
VampiRing
Forum Message
Previous messagePost on the new forumNext message

City:Roma IT
Personal Data:Male, born: December 29 1975
HomePage or other cool site:http://www.takeaplay.net
Membership22years 307days ago.
Last Login150days 14h ago.
Last Move3years 21days ago.
ivanhawk is currently Offline!


Message header
Area/Game:Blue Max
Topic:Scenarios
Subject:Re: No more Gullivers
Posted by: ivanhawk - 21years 209days ago.
Message text
imdog wrote:
PaoloL wrote:
gugliandalf wrote:
I've just withdrawn the following scenarios:

[...]

Now, earn your scores and stats in fair combat.



Nice work, Gugliandalf.

bye
Paolo


I think the situation is

1. Once there is a system, there is someone wish to abuse it.
2. Players sometime didn't look for balanced game. they want something unbalnaced
3. Some do like stat, some don't
4. someone spoil the system by using newbie killing system.

My suggestion is

short term
I think freedom is based on trust. As right now the system is spoiled by somebody (we all know who they are) but as
A. Youplay.it is a place for fun. The webmaster don't want any harsh action such as stop acct or limit somebody creation of games.
B. They are already ovearloaded and to list is too long.

1) The most simple solution is deleted all extreme unbalanced situation. But this "extreme" is very controversal is 1 vs 3 extremely unbalanced? if 1 DrI vs 3 Snipe. YES, 1 Bristol vs 3 SSI, NO. But how can a Newbie know it!

2) to solve it. We must stated clearly in the description. AND when in the Joined description box or EVEN in the game listing page. in Bold Pt 36 "Extremely unbalanced Scenario, the infavor side could be expected live less than 5 rounds for inexperienced Pilot."

In the long run
1) Could we put some limiation on the scenario.
example, challenged game only, only on 8x8 maps,
2) limit "someone" no. of games creating in one time.
3) Even for opened games, if open for 5 days and not filled, delete it (as the no. of people in youplay is growing, I think the pass rules should changed)

just my 0.001 cents

P.


Ok, this all makes sense.

But.

Let's face it, guys, the real problem is not the scenarios, it's rules and map size. As I already said a Snipe vs. 3 Dr.I can be a really fun scenario played with advanced rules on a small map. Play the same scenario on a 17x12 map and PUFF!, the fun is all gone. Why? Map size, which makes it impossible for the Fokkers to make it home safely. Play the same scenario on 8x8 map with loser (i.e. standard) rules, and the faun is gone all the same. Why? Standard rules, which rob Blue Max of the chance element (which exists in the real world, don't forget it) and make the Snipe unbeatable.

Me, I like unbalanced scenarios a lot more than the so called 'even' scennarios, and I'd hate to dogfight only planes that can move like me, shoot like me and spend fuel like me. And one more thing: do you realy think that back in 1917 the guys in Jasta 11 or in the R.A.F. thought about how balanced their battles were?
CIAO

ivanhawk
FeuerKugel Jagdgeschwader

Back to the messages list
Messages thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

21years 211days gugliandalf [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 211days imdog Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 210days gugliandalf Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 210days Sabelkatten Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 210days gugliandalf Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 210days marcuza Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 210days flying_neko Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 210days morsac Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 210days marcuza Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 209days gugliandalf Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 210days ivanhawk Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 210days flying_neko Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 210days marcuza Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 210days tomski Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
 21years 209days Ashtar Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 209days gugliandalf Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 209days ivanhawk Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 209days gugliandalf Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
 21years 209days ivanhawk Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
21years 209days PaoloL Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
 21years 209days imdog Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
 21years 209days ivanhawk Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
  21years 209days imdog Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
   21years 209days Ensign Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
    21years 208days imdog Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
 21years 209days sven3012 Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
  21years 208days Zif Re: [BM][SCE] No more Gullivers
Next thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

21years 207days Capt-Tuttle [BM][BUG] Game 103445
21years 207days flying_neko Re: [BM][BUG] Game 103445
Previous thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

21years 208days Regicide Re: [BM][SCE] to create new scenarios
Page generated in: 26.5625 milliseconds.