LOGIN
User Name
Password
Remember me


Register...Forgot password?
Main menu
Leagues
Gonzaga
Blue Max
Cartagena
Wooden Ships...
King Me!
VampiRing
Forum Message
Previous messagePost on the new forumNext message

City:North of Rome IT
Personal Data:Male,
HomePage or other cool site:http://www.selfcontrolfreak.com/pakken.html
Membership21years 148days ago.
Last Login1day 1h ago.
Last Move1day 1h ago.
BlackSheep is currently Offline!Send a mail to BlackSheep


Message header
Area/Game:General
Topic:Suggestions, improvement, critics
Subject:Re: Player Rating
Posted by: BlackSheep - 7years 158days ago.
Message text
Electro wrote:
gugliandalf wrote:
Electro wrote:


About that, I think a better way to compute rank would be, instead of Kills - Deaths, Kills / Deaths. I guess it wouldn't tale a lot of coding...

Subtraction rewards the sheer number of games played, while ratio better reflects quality playing.

Just a sample, compare with the actual rank:

Rank Player Kills Deaths K/D
1 markrendl 7262 1904 3,81
2 scotireb 9805 2805 3,50
3 warrax 1751 678 2,58
...


I tend to agree, and will implement this simple calculation, but kill 'stealing' can sometimes skew this. There have been many games where I've done all the damage, only to have a teammate shoot down, or sink, the opponent. In WS&IM, unless you are part of the final salvo, you don't get any credit for the sinking.

I'm looking for a better overall rating system that includes many other factors. Overall points should be a factor. Depending on the game, damage done and rounds played should count for something.

Even the type of plane, or ship, and the scenario, might count for something. Not to mention what Derek posted about the quality of your opponent.

It exist another information provided by that page, that is the medium of points scored per game by each player, that can help you telling how good a player is.
I think that a kill ratio is a good addition and should quite easy to add, but we should not forget what we already have.
Then, computing the damage inflicted, in Blue Max, is partly included in the victory point system since you get one point per turn you stayed aloft, 25 points for killing an opponent and then, each turn you shoot on an enemy, you get as many points as the value of the column you use on the CRT.
This last thing wasn't present in the original Blue Max, but Phil Hall said that it was really nice and had thought it he would have added to the game since the start.
I don't remember if something like that exist in Wooden Ship, but in case I think it could easly implemented.
These are my 2 cents.

Back to the messages list
Messages thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

7years 173days Electro [IDEAS] Player Rating
7years 173days derekticus Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
 7years 173days shermanguy Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
 7years 172days Electro Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
  7years 171days derekticus Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
   7years 170days mark41974 Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
    7years 169days shermanguy Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
     7years 169days Electro Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
      7years 169days BlackSheep Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
      7years 168days mark41974 Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
       7years 162days shermanguy Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
      7years 160days gugliandalf Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
       7years 160days Electro Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
        7years 159days gugliandalf Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
        7years 159days Electro Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
         7years 159days gugliandalf Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
          7years 158days BlackSheep Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
           7years 158days gugliandalf Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
        7years 158days BlackSheep Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
         7years 158days Electro Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
          7years 145days BlackSheep Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
           7years 145days GraysGhost Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
            7years 145days dcr66 Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
             7years 144days GraysGhost Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
              7years 144days Longneck Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
              7years 128days mark41974 Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
               7years 124days shermanguy Re: [IDEAS] Player Rating
Next thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

7years 124days darken [BM][BUG] Possible Rudder Jam Bug
7years 124days markrendl Re: [BM][BUG] Possible Rudder Jam Bug
 7years 124days darken Re: [BM][BUG] Possible Rudder Jam Bug
Previous thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

7years 132days spaceghostx9 [CA][SYS] CARTAGENA GAME #802905
7years 132days Electro Re: [CA][SYS] CARTAGENA GAME #802905
 7years 132days spaceghostx9 Re: [CA][SYS] CARTAGENA GAME #802905
  7years 132days Electro Re: [CA][SYS] CARTAGENA GAME #802905
Page generated in: 24.70703 milliseconds.