LOGIN
User Name
Password
Remember me


Register...Forgot password?
Main menu
Leagues
Gonzaga
Blue Max
Cartagena
Wooden Ships...
King Me!
VampiRing
Forum Message
Previous messagePost on the new forumNext message

City:Capital District, NY US
HomePage or other cool site:http://www.swa-gaming.org
Membership19years 287days ago.
Last Login2years 154days ago.
Last Move5years 173days ago.
TXWard is currently Offline!Send a mail to TXWard


Message header
Area/Game:General
Topic:Other
Subject:Re: A small complaint
Posted by: TXWard - 15years 290days ago.
Message text
GraysGhost wrote:
TXWard wrote:
TXWard wrote:
GraysGhost wrote:

You should worry - I cannot fly under my Country's Flag - I'm English but apparently England isn't a Country.

The Vatican City is - but England with the Queen of England isn't.

So three letters of your alphabet - think yourself lucky you have a Swedish Flag to fly under.

Not that I'm bitter or anything....


Now that the flags have been added, can someone explain how England, in its current non-devolved state, is fundamentally different than a Canadian Province, an American State, or an Italian Region? It is governed by the UK Parliament, which is different than the condition that Scotland and Wales have been in for the past decade or so.

Not that it matters much to me beyond curiosity, but just that so much ado was made about it but it seems to me the site was not in err previously and I'd like to be enlightened by those who know more.

Are any Brits pondering this or is the lack of response supposed to indicate a lack of a difference? I have to think there is some sort of fundamental distinction that can be made.


Sorry hadn't seen your posting.

Can you tell me the difference between Italy as a member state of the European Union and Texas a member state of the American Union?

A Treaty is signed, a common currency is used and is Italy actually a nation any more? If it is then why isn't England after a Treaty was signed and a common currency started in the United Kingdom?

If you say that it is because the Act of Union of 1707 was 300 years ago, then when did time become the deciding factor? 10, 20, 100, 200 years - when?

You see once Treaties are drawn up and signed the lines become blurred.

So England is a Country regardless of government, politics or treaties simply because it always has been. The provinces/states of the USA, Italy, Canada et al have never been real independent nations though I will concede that some City States do still exist - Monaco & The Vatican City etc.

So my understanding is that England is a Country, others are regions or states of a union, otherwise are you going to start asking questions about English Counties all of which have elected legislatures that pass local laws that are only applicable to that County?

Even I'm not that nutty


Member states of the European Union retain their sovereignty and representation of themselves globally in the United Nations and Olympics, correct? Texas, in becoming a state of the US, agreed to allow the United States to represent it on the world stage. Texas is governed at a national level by the United States; Italy is governed by Italy. Those are fundamental differences, and they do not seem to be the case for England, which is why I pondered the actual distinctions you are trying to make.

You state that "once a country, always a country", yet there are countries that no longer exist as such (e.g. East Germany, Czechoslovakia). Are you saying that the state of Texas, for example, should be considered a country still solely because at one point in time (during it's time as an independent Republic) it was one?

Country, nation, and state are terms that are often (albeit often erroneously) interchanged. We know there are many terms in British English and American English that mean completely different things, as well as items that are identical but use very different terms to define them. One has to wonder if something similar is happening here as well. That's why I am curious as to what exactly distinguishes England from being a "member state" of Great Britain.

Back to the messages list
Messages thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

15years 302days ThunderBolt [OT] A small complaint
15years 302days imdog Re: [OT] A small complaint
15years 302days ThunderBolt Re: [OT] A small complaint
 15years 301days GraysGhost Re: [OT] A small complaint
  15years 300days captecoli Re: [OT] A small complaint
  15years 298days GraysGhost Re: [OT] A small complaint
   15years 298days brewk001 Re: [OT] A small complaint
    15years 298days captecoli Re: [OT] A small complaint
    15years 298days GraysGhost Re: [OT] A small complaint
    15years 298days BlackSheep Re: [OT] A small complaint
     15years 298days brewk001 Re: [OT] A small complaint
      15years 297days BlackSheep Re: [OT] A small complaint
       15years 297days brewk001 Re: [OT] A small complaint
       15years 296days GraysGhost Re: [OT] A small complaint
        15years 296days Bombadil Re: [OT] A small complaint
        15years 296days FENRIS Re: [OT] A small complaint
        15years 295days BlueDragon Re: [OT] A small complaint
        15years 295days BlackSheep Re: [OT] A small complaint
  15years 295days Nick Re: [OT] A small complaint
  15years 295days GraysGhost Re: [OT] A small complaint
  15years 295days Bombadil Re: [OT] A small complaint
  15years 295days FENRIS Re: [OT] A small complaint
  15years 295days FENRIS Re: [OT] A small complaint
  15years 293days brewk001 Re: [OT] A small complaint
  15years 290days Odeiiii Re: [OT] A small complaint
  15years 294days TXWard Re: [OT] A small complaint
   15years 290days TXWard Re: [OT] A small complaint
    15years 290days GraysGhost Re: [OT] A small complaint
    15years 290days TXWard Re: [OT] A small complaint
    15years 290days BlackSheep Re: [OT] A small complaint
     15years 290days TXWard Re: [OT] A small complaint
      15years 290days GraysGhost Re: [OT] A small complaint
       15years 290days TXWard Re: [OT] A small complaint
        15years 289days GraysGhost Re: [OT] A small complaint
         15years 289days BlueDragon Re: [OT] A small complaint
    15years 290days Bombadil Re: [OT] A small complaint
     15years 290days FENRIS Re: [OT] A small complaint
     15years 290days FENRIS Re: [OT] A small complaint
15years 299days BlackSheep Re: [OT] A small complaint
15years 296days arkon Re: [OT] A small complaint
 15years 295days BlackSheep Re: [OT] A small complaint
15years 290days Bombadil Re: [OT] A small complaint
 15years 290days FENRIS Re: [OT] A small complaint
Next thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

15years 313days GraysGhost [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
15years 312days brewk001 Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
15years 311days rainbow Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
15years 308days brewk001 Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
15years 311days Der_Kobra Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
15years 310days GraysGhost Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
15years 310days Der_Kobra Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
15years 310days GraysGhost Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
 15years 310days desco34 Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
15years 310days rainbow Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
 15years 309days tlamb67 Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
  15years 309days rainbow Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
15years 308days desco34 Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
 15years 308days pokerguy Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
  15years 308days desco34 Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
  15years 307days GraysGhost Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
   15years 306days desco34 Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
    15years 306days Natador_NMcHarg Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
     15years 306days Bubba6518 Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
  15years 306days brewk001 Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
   15years 304days Natador_NMcHarg Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
    15years 303days Natador_NMcHarg Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
     15years 290days GraysGhost Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
      15years 289days tlamb67 Re: [BM][TOUR] FA Cup Quarter Finals
Previous thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

15years 297days Falconfab [BM][IDEAS] Extra point for covering
15years 290days Falconfab Re: [BM][IDEAS] Extra point for covering
Page generated in: 33.39844 milliseconds.