LOGIN
User Name
Password
Remember me


> Not a member yet?
> Forgot your password?
Main menu
Preferred site
Get Firefox!
Forum Message
City:Indiana US
Personal Data:Male, born: June 30 1963
Membership20years 223days ago.
Last Login115days 16h ago.
Last Move220days 19h ago.
Longneck is currently Offline!Send a mail to Longneck

Message header
Area/Game:Wooden Ships & Iron Men
1Topic:Bugs and Improvements
Subject:Re: boarding question
Posted by: Longneck - 15years 250days ago.
Message text
BlueDragon wrote:
The rules do not talk about "abandoned ships", they only talk about ships losing their last crew unit: they say that without crew, ships cannot move/fire, until some more crew is put on board.
They do not lose owner, they are simply ships without crew.


Karl makes a good point here. The "friendly" TBP can never win, but both should have an equal chance. BlueDragon: I agree the rules are silent on this, but one without a crew could be considered neither friendly nor unfriendly. We imply that now by allowing transfers between adjacent friendly ships that aren't grappled or fouled, but you CANNOT TBP to an abandoned "friendly" ship without grappling/fouling. That's inconsistent.

If there's nothing clear in the rules, I would vote for a "house rule" where ALL transfers to abandoned ships should act as OBPs.
Messages thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

15years 252days karllagov boarding question
15years 252days dcr66 Re: boarding question
 15years 252days karllagov Re: boarding question
  15years 252days Longneck Re: boarding question
   15years 251days karllagov Re: boarding question
    15years 251days BlueDragon Re: boarding question
     15years 251days karllagov Re: boarding question
      15years 251days BlueDragon Re: boarding question
       15years 250days karllagov Re: boarding question
       15years 250days Longneck Re: boarding question
        15years 250days BlueDragon Re: boarding question
         15years 250days karllagov Re: boarding question
         15years 247days Longneck Re: boarding question
          15years 246days BlueDragon Re: boarding question
           15years 245days BlueDragon Re: boarding question
Page generated in: 18.75 milliseconds.